Customer Reviews | See What Our Coffee Lovers Are Saying
Cute blue octopus holding a hot coffee mug, representing sustainable coffee and ocean-themed designs
Cute blue octopus holding a hot coffee mug, representing sustainable coffee and ocean-themed designs
This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

🏝️ FREE SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS! 📦

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ RAVE-WORTHY BREWS 👏🤩

🔥 ROASTED FRESH JUST FOR YOU 👊😎

SPECIALTY-GRADE QUALITY 👌🧐

Cart 0

FREE SHIPPING is all yours! 📦🙌 You are $0 away from free shipping.
No more products available for purchase

Products

Look at you go! This cart is bound to make a splash, sending ripples of impact across our seven seas. ❤︎

Subtotal Free
View cart
Taxes & discount codes are calculated at checkout

Our Reviews

✦ Let Our Customers Speak For Us ✦

Based on 87 reviews
100%
(87)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
Honestly delicious

This one instantly feels like a tropical treat. The mango flavor is bright and sweet, and super refreshing. Super smooth, no bitterness, and honestly delicious, highly recommend if you want something uplifting and flavorful.

Smooth!

Really smooth black tea with a natural peach flavor that feels light and refreshing. It’s not overly sweet, just a clean, fruity taste with a little floral note. Tastes great hot or iced, and I love that it feels like a healthier swap for sugary drinks. Definitely recommend this one!

WHOLE / 16 OZ (7% MORE VALUE)
My dream version of Nutella in a cup

I love the hazelnut flavor. Not only because I generally enjoy trying different coffee flavors and this one is excellent, but because it reminds me of my favorite snack - Nutella. This is amazing coffee and makes me smile every time!!

WHOLE / 16 OZ (7% MORE VALUE)
Just the right touch!

just the right touch of vanilla—not artificial or overpowering, but pleasantly sweet and aromatic!! I enjoy this coffee for my afternoon pick me up, and I love experimenting with different flavors!

WHOLE / 5 LB (35% MORE VALUE)
Love!

I love this espresso blend! The beans are fresh and aromatic, and the dark roast delivers a rich, bold flavor without being bitter. Smooth body, works beautifully for straight espresso shots and also holds up well in milk-based drinks like cappuccinos and lattes. Great everyday espresso bean for my favorite coffee machine!

Didn't Disappoint

Rwanda was the first Captain’s Compass I tried once they opened it up for non subscribers. It was well-balanced and with enough flavor to make each sip interesting. The bag showed up fresh and the smell alone tells you it was roasted to order. Feels like a treat compared to my usual store bought coffee 😅

A Light & Bright Wave of Flavor

I love this light roast. It conjures memories of surfing in Tamarindo - minus my copious wipeouts, of course. The coarse grind through a French press has been a game-changer, bringing out a sweet, bright acidity. If you love lighter roasts, you simply have to try it.

Smooth & Delightful: The Earl of Earls!

Full disclosure: Earl Grey is my favorite type of tea - standards (and snobbery) were high. Wonder Waves rose to the occasion.

Whether by itself or mixed, the flavor is incredibly smooth; the hints of citrus give it such a nice splash. Also, you're going to fall in love with the bergamot scent. I honestly cannot recommend it enough!

Full Flavor

Usually skeptical about decaf since so many fall flat but this one totally surprised me. I like that it’s made with a chemical-free process, so it stays super clean with no weird aftertaste and all the delicious flavor is still there.

Deep and flavorful

I’m a dark roast fan through and through and this one’s impressively smooth. Deep flavor all the way, without any bitterness.

Nails it ...

I went to a coffee plantation when in Costa Rica 6 years ago and had a light roast coffee while there. It was the best coffee I've ever had. I brought back 10 pounds, ran out, and was looking for something that matched the flavor. I finally found this one that matches. I use it in my espresso machine or my coffee machine ... and a cold brew for the first time this week. It's great in all forms. The cold brew is literally perfect for a summer iced coffee. If you let the espresso shot come off its hot level just a bit, the flavor is off-the-charts tasty.

Smooth & chocolatey

I cold-brew this blend ready-to-drink (not concentrate). Smooth chocolatey notes with a clean finish and a touch of sweetness every time.

Perfect for hot days

Great for all seasons but stands out in the summer and warmer climates like here in Florida. Light, crisp, and flavorful. Brew it strong, let it cool, and pour it over ice!

COARSE / 12 OZ (CLASSIC CHOICE)
Absolutely loved this coffee

Absolutely loved this coffee. Could smell how fresh it was as soon as I opened the bag and by being able to order the coarse grounds, I am finally using the correct type of coffee for my french press. Very flavorful and would highly recommend.

Couldn't recommend more!

Love the way this smells while brewing almost as much as I love the taste! Couldn't recommend more!

Love it!

Amazing beans for making delicious at home lattes! Pairs very well with oat milk and a dash of cinnamon :)

Smooth and Rich, incredible coffee

This stuff’s legit. Smooth and rich. Stronger than your average medium roast but not as heavy or punchy as a dark. Hits that sweet spot.

Actually balanced

I’ve tried a bunch of coffees that claim to be “balanced” but this one actually is. It’s the one I reach for on slow mornings when I can take the time to savor it. I drink it black and it’s honestly perfect that way.

A fun surprise every month

Been getting Captain’s Compass for a bit now and honestly, I look forward to it. The coffee’s always fresh, super smooth, and I love not knowing what’s coming next. Plus it feels good knowing it’s helping the ocean in some way. Kinda makes the whole morning routine better.

FINE / 16 OZ (7% MORE VALUE)
My new go-to espresso! Tastes amazing and gets

My new go-to espresso! Tastes amazing and gets the job done :)

Incredible Cup Everytime!!

Mangrove Mist is an absolute standout. Bright, smooth, and naturally sweet, it delivers a clean, refreshing cup that’s perfect for any time of day. The aroma is incredible, and you can taste the quality. Wonder Waves nailed it — fresh, beautifully packaged, and truly delicious. Highly recommend!

Refreshingly light and fruity

Refreshingly light and fruity. Great for iced tea in the summer time.

Beautifully balanced

Great quality and not bitter at all. Tastes fresh and floral!

Really tasty chai

Perfect balance of spice without being too strong. Smells amazing when brewing!

WHOLE / 12 OZ (CLASSIC CHOICE)
Always hits right

My go-to espresso, brewed in my bialetti mocha pot every morning :)